Comparing Intramedullary Nailing, External Fixation, and External Fixation followed by Intramedullary Nailing as management for open fractures of the tibial shaft: a Systematic Review
Keywords:External Fixators, Intramedullary Nailing, Open Fracture, Tibial Fracture
Background: The treatment of open fractures of the tibial shaft is often a dilemma since it requires particular caution and individual assistance for each case. Methods and Findings: Systematic review of the literature was conducted on the following databases: PubMed and VHL from 2000 to 2013 aiming to compare Intramedullary Nailing (IM Nailing), External Fixation (EF), and EF followed by IM Nailing in the treatment of open fractures of the tibial shaft. After analysis by inclusion criteria 24 articles met the eligibility criteria. The healing time was under 32 weeks, and the nonunion and defective healing rates were under 13.35% and 16.6%, respectively. The infection rate ranged from 3% to 53% for patients treated with EF as definitive management; from 0% to 22% for those treated with IM Nailing as definitive management; and from 0% to 16.7% for those who underwent EF followed by IM Nailing. Conclusion: The cases treated with EF as definitive management presented shorter healing time as for the analyzed samples. The nonunion cases with greater percentages were those of EF followed by IM Nailing. The studies using IM Nailing as definitive management presented more healing cases defective. Even though few studies analyze hospital stay, it was found to be shorter in the sample treated with EF as definitive management.Â
Rezende MP,Silva WRS.AnÃ¡lise dos Resultados de fraturas expostas da diÃ¡fise da tÃbia tratados com fixaÃ§Ã£o externa e posteriormente conversÃ£o com haste intramedular.AHMâ€“Autarquia Hospitalar Municipal.Secretaria.2012; s.n:20.
Bhandari M,Guyatt G,Tornetta P,Schemitsch E,Swiontkowski M,Sanders D et al.Study to prospectively evaluate reamed intramedually nails in patients with tibial fractures(S.P.R.I.N.T.):study rationale and design.BMC Musculoskelet Disord.2008; 9:91.
Yokoyama K,Uchino M,Nakamura K,Ohtsuka H,Suzuki T,Boku T et al. Risk factors for deep infection in secondary intramedullary nailing after external fixation for open tibial fractures.Injury. 2006; 37(6):554-60.
Hungria JOS,Mercadante MT. OsteossÃntese provisÃ³ria das fraturas expostas da diÃ¡fise da tÃbia com fixador externo nÃ£o transfixante. Rev. bras. ortop. 2008; 43(1-2):31-40.
Keeling JJ, Gwinn DE, Tintle SM, Andersen RC,McGuigan FX. Short-term outcomes of severe opne wartime tibial fractures treated with ring external fixation.J Bone Joint Surg Am.2008; 90(12):2643-51.
Park HJ, Uchino M, Nakamura M, Ueno M, Kojima Y, Itoman M, Yokoyama K, Suzuki T, Nemoto M. Immediate interlocking nailing versus external fixation followed by delayed interlocking nailing for Gustilo type IIIBopen tibial fractures.J Orthop Surg (Hong Kong).2007; 15(2):131-6.
Ueno M,Yokoyama K,Nakamura K,Uchino M,Suzuki T,Itoman M. Early unreamed intramedullary nailing without a safety interval ad simultaneous flap coverage following external fixation in type IIIB open tibial fractures: a report of four successful cases.Injury.2006; 37(3):289-94.
Wani N,Baba A,Kangoo K,Mir M. Role of early Ilizarov ring fixator in the difinitive management of type II, IIIA and IIIB open tibial shaft fractures. Int Orthop.2011; 35(6):915-23.
DallÂ´Oca C,Christodoulidis A,Bortolazzi R,Bortolozzi P,Lavini F. Treatment of 103 displaced tibial diaphyseal fractures with a radiolucent unilateral external fixator.Arch Orthop Trauma Surg. 2010; 130(11):1377-82.
Inan M,Halici M,Ayan I,Tuncel M,Karaoglu S. Treatment of type IIIA open fractures of tibial shaft with Ilizarov external fixator versus undreamed tiba nailing.Arch Orthop Trauma Surg.2007; 127(8):617-23.
Kaftandziev I,Pejkova S,Saveski J. Operative treatment of III grade open fractures of the tibial diaphysis.Prilozi.2006; 27(1):121-31.
Naique SB, Pearse M, Nachanhal J. Management of severe open tibial fractures:the need for combined orthopaedic and plastic surgical treatment inspecialist centers. J Bone Joint Surg Br.2006; 88(3):351-7.
Kesemenli CC,Kapukaya A,SubaÅŸi M,Arslan H,NecmioÄŸlu S,KayikÃ§i C. Early prophylactic autogenous bone grafting in type III open tibial fractures.Acta Orthop Belg.2004; 70(4):327-31.
Hosny G,Fadel M. Ilizarov external fixator for open fractures of the tibial shaft.Int Orthop.2003; 27(5):303-6.
Claes L,Grass R,Schmickal T,Kisse B,Eggers C,Gerngross H,Mutschler W,Arand M,Wintermeyer T, Wentzensen A(2002)Monitoring and healing analysis of 100 tibial shaft fractures.Langenbecks Arch Surg.387(3-4):146-52.
Agrawal A,Chauhan VD,Maheshwari RK,Juyal AK(2013)Primary Nailing in the Open Fractures of the Tibia-Is it worth?J Clin Diagn Res.7(6):1125-30.
Hungri JOS,Mercadante MT.Open tibial shaft fractures( 2013)Treatment with intramedullary nailing after provisional stabilization with non penetrating external fixator.Rev. bras. ortop.48(6):482-490.
Bhandari M,Guyatt G,Tornetta P,Schemitsch EH,Swiontkowki M,Sanders D,Walter SD(2008) Randomized Trial of Reamed and Unreamed Intramedullary Nailing of Tibial Shaft Fractures.J Bone Joint Surg Am.90(12):2567-78.
Sakaki MA,Crocci AT,Zumiotti AV(2007)Comparative study of the locked Intramedullary nail and ender pins in the treatment of tibial diaphyseal fractures.Clinics.62(4):455-64.
Tielinen L,Lindahl JE,Turkiainen EJ(2007)Acute undreamed intramedullary nailing and soft tissue recons truction with muscle flaps for the treatment of severe open tibial shaft fractures.Injury.38(8):906-12.
Djahangiri A, Garofalo R, Chevalley F, Leyvraz PF, Wettstein M, Borens O, Schizas C, Mouhsine E. Closed and open grade Iand II tibial shaft fractures treated by reamed intramedullary nailing. Med Princ Pract.2006; 15(4):293-8.
Oh CW, Bae SY, Jung DY, Oh JK. Treatment of open tibial shaft fractures using tightly fitted interlocking nailing.Int Orthop.2006; 30(5):333-7.
Shah RK, Moehring HD, Singh RP, Dhakal A. Surgical Implant Generation Network(SIGN) intramedullary nailing of open fractures of the tibia.Int Orthop.2004; 28(3):163-6.
Oh CW,Park BC,Ihn JC,Park HJ(2001)Primary unreamed intramedullary nailing for open fractures of the tiba.Int Orthop.24(6):338-41.
Authors who publish with this journal agree to the following terms:
- Authors retain copyright and grant the journal right of first publication with the work simultaneously licensed under aÂ Creative Commons Attribution LicenseÂ that allows others to share the work with an acknowledgement of the work's authorship and initial publication in this journal.
- Authors are able to enter into separate, additional contractual arrangements for the non-exclusive distribution of the journal's published version of the work (e.g., post it to an institutional repository or publish it in a book), with an acknowledgement of its initial publication in this journal.
- Authors are permitted and encouraged to post their work online (e.g., in institutional repositories or on their website) prior to and during the submission process, as it can lead to productive exchanges, as well as earlier and greater citation of published work (SeeÂ The Effect of Open AccessÂ and Benefits of Publishing Open Access).